Showing posts with label tailings. Show all posts
Showing posts with label tailings. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 18, 2009

Tailings dam failures and the price of commodities

A couple of weeks ago the University of Alberta hosted a conference entitled "Tailings and Mine Waste 2009". Impressively, all of the presentations from the meeting have been posted online on an FTP site here. Most of the presentations focus upon technical aspects of tailings facility design, but there is a very interesting talk from Michael Davis and Todd Martin from AMEC online as a pdf here. This presentation examines the relationship between the occurrence of tailings dam failures and the economic cycle of commodities. I should say upfront that I find parts of the presentation rather uncomfortable (especially the back-slapping aspects of the last slide regarding the oil sands industry), but the core point of the presentation is certainly thought provoking.

In the presentation they note that between 1968 and August 2009 there were 143 documented tailings dam failures worldwide. However, the occurrence of these failures appears to be cyclic with time, with peaks in the periods 1976-8, 1984-6, 1990-2, 1998-2000 and 2008-now. They compared these peaks with the cyclicity of the global copper and gold prices. The key part of the presentation is a table that compared the timing of the peaks:

The authors' conclusion is that there is a relationship between the peak in commodities prices and the occurrence of tailings dam failures, with a lag between the two of about two years. I must admit that I am a little unconvinced by the statistics of this analysis (I would like to see a proper regression analysis to see whether this link is statistically valid - and to be fair the authors recognise that this is not a scientifically-rigorous analysis), but the central point is one that is certainly very thought provoking. Increased commodity prices drive increased exploitation. The relationship between the peak in prices an the peak in accidents is ascribed by the authors to:
  1. The rush to mine quickly means that design and construction standards may be low;
  2. Rapid turn-over of key staff as new (presumably lucrative) opportunities arise during the boom;
  3. The boom drives the development of resources in areas that are known to be difficult;
  4. after the boom there are pressures to cut costs as commodity prices decline;
  5. The boom drives the use of inappropriate designs imported from other locations;
  6. There may be a lack of independent review, presumably to avoid the time delays and costs associated with this.
The implications of all this are sobering. The most recent boom ended in 2008, and the average lag is 25 months for copper and 29 months for gold. This should mean that the peak in tailings dam failures should be expected 12 to 30 months from now.

Hat-tip to Jack Caldwell's excellent I think Mining blog for highlighting this paper.

Tuesday, September 16, 2008

Loss of life in the China and Egypt landslidesp

Just a brief update on the latest estimate of the loss of life in the landslides last week in Egypt and China:


Taoshi (Shanxi): as of 16th September the official death toll is 259 people. Searches continue (see above AFP image).


Manshiet Nasser (Cairo): as of 16th September the official death toll is 92 people. It appears that recovery actions have now ceased as the site is considered to be too dangerous. There are likely to be many victims still buried. It is difficult to see how recovery operations can be safely undertaken under blocks such as the above (Reuters image).

Sunday, September 14, 2008

Loss of life in the Manshiet Nasser (Cairo) and Taoshi township (Shaanxi) landslides

Xinhua is now reporting that the death toll in the Shaanxi landslide has now reached 254. They also report that the recovery teams are yet to search two channels in which local people believe more bodies are buried

AFP is reporting that the number of fatalities in the Manshiet Nasser (Cairo) landslide is now 82 people, with at least another week of recovery work to follow. Interestingly. they also report that "Residents have blamed the rock slide on work that had been going on for several weeks on the Moqattam hill overlooking the shantytown". It would be interesting to find out more about this work.

Thursday, September 11, 2008

Updates on the Cairo and Shaanxi landslides

It is unusual to have two major stories running simultaneously about landslides so here is a combined update:

1. The Manshiet Nasser landslide in Cairo

The death toll in the Cairo landslide disaster continues to rise - it is now officially 69 people. There seems to be considerable confusion about how many people are left trapped - but is fair to say that there is now no hope of rescuing anyone alive. The magnitude of the task in terms of recovery is shown well by the picture above.

There is some discussion on the newswires about the causes, with several suggestions that sewage in the joints may have played a role. To me this is far from clear. There are also now suggestions that quarrying may have occurred on the rock face - this would be the first thing that I would look at if I was investigating the slide.

Meanwhile, there appears to be considerable political fall-out over both the government's failure to recognise the threat posed by this slope (see here) and the slowness of the response. This has led the government to seal off the site. One wonders whether we will ever know the true toll of this event.

2. The Taoshi township flowslide in Shaaxi



The pictures emerging from the Taoshi township site continue to horrify. The official death toll is now 128, but there can be no hope of anyone else being found alive. Officials are now admitting that the number of missing people is "several hundred". The debris flow was reportedly three stories high and 600 m wide when it hit an office building, a market and several houses. At the time the market was just starting and there was a meeting, attended by over 100 people, in the offices of the mine company. Only three people survived the meeting.

Again, the difficulties of recovering victims here may make it difficult to estimate the true impact of this event.


Wednesday, September 10, 2008

China tailings dam disaster death toll

Reuters image of the search for victims

Reuters is now reporting that the number of fatalities in the China tailings dam disaster (landslide / debris flow) is now 128 people. A unknown number remain buried in the debris. Interestingly, Xinhua appears to have ceased reporting on the event (corrected: they do now have a report), amongst suggestions that journalists are being kept away.

The difficulties facing the rescuers are clear from the above image. Recovering anyone alive from within that deposit is very unlikely.

Monday, September 8, 2008

Updated: A flow slide disaster in China

UPDATED: New image of the site added
UPDATED: Google Earth image of location added.



Update: This image from http://aboutxinjiang.com/ shows the site of the failure. This confirms both the magnitude of the event and the type.

This has been a terrible week for landslide disasters. Sadly, news emerged yesterday of yet another, this time in Taoshi township, Linfen County in Shaanxi province. I think that I have managed to identify the location - see Google Earth image below (location is 35°54' N, 111°30' E). Initial reports suggested that 26 people had been killed; this has now been increased to 34, but it seems likely that the death toll is much higher.

Details are a little sketchy at the moment, but the suggestion appear to be that heavy rain caused a tailings dam to fail, releasing a large amount of material that swept as a debris flow down the valley. Xinhua has a limited commentary but a rather interesting set of images of the disaster:

The Xinhua report states that "The mud-rock flow ... destroyed a three-story office building, a market and some villagers' houses in the valley. Witness said the flow roared down the valley and washed away the market and the houses in a few minutes."

The description and images of the landslide suggest that this was what is termed a flowslide - this is a large volume debris flow consisting of soil, rock and water. They are able to move exceptionally fast and to travel large distances. Sadly the mining industry has a terrible record of flowslides originating from spoil heaps or the failure of tailings dams. Examples include:

There is a full if rather horrifying list of these events here. In most more developed countries the accidents at Aberfan, Buffalo Creek and Stava have meant that mine dumps are very tightly regulated, meaning that the accident rate is now low. The impact of not doing so are graphically illustrated by this pair of images (see this web page) of the Stava event in Italy (click on the image for a better view):

Here, 200,000 cubic metres of fluorite tailings flowed over 4 km downstream at over 90 km/h.